This time I really went and got more fabric, including another trip up to Marden's in Maine. Unfortunately I didn't realize that they close so early on weekends, but I still did some significant damage in a half hour!
Instead of having to rush, I could take my time and actually redo anything I wasn't satisfied with. Well, that turned out to be almost every single square! I have enough rejects to make another quilt!
The result is that I love every square of this quilt!